Design
and Development of Aloe vera Lotions and Determination of Their Sun
Protection Factor
V. Sai
Kishore*, N. Balaji, K. Srikanth
and J. Hemanth
Bapatla College of
Pharmacy, Bapatla-522101
*Corresponding
Author E-mail: voiceofsaikishore@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Sun light causes damage to skin by inducing photoaging, photocarcinogenisis. Aloe vera is
most popular in the treatment of dermatological disorders. In this study, in to
the calamine lotion aloe gel (conventional lotion), a novel lotion containing
freeze dried aloe powder beads and freeze dried aloe powder lotion were incorporated. The aim of this study is
to compare the efficacy of novel lotion (freeze dried aloe powder beads and
freeze dried aloe powder lotion) and conventional lotion (aloe gel). Aloe gel
beads were prepared by using the ionic gelation
technique. Beads were in spherical shape with a diameter of 0.510±0.143 mm. The
novel, conventional lotion were evaluated for the colour,
PH of preparation, sedimentation volume, redispersibility,
spreadability, rheological, In vitro and In vivo sun
protection factor(SPF). For
conventional lotion SPF was found to be 6.39±0.1 where as for novel lotion
containing freeze dried aloe powder beads SPF was found to be 13.52±0.21. It
was found that novel lotion containing freeze dried aloe powder beads provides
greater sunscreen protection than the conventional lotion. In vivo SPF values for novel lotion are higher than the
conventional lotion.
KEYWORDS:
INTRODUCTION:
Skin or the cutaneous layer
is the external covering of the body and is part of the integumentary
system, that protects the body from surrounding environment and acts as sensory
organ1. It is made up of three layers namely epidermis, dermis and
hypodermis. Sunlight has three forms: infrared (heat/visible), visible light
and ultraviolet. Ultraviolet light is classified into three categories: UVA (320
to 400nm) also known as black light causes tanning. UVB (290 to 320 nm) causes
damage in the form of sunburn and UVC (100 to 290 nm) which is filtered out by
the atmosphere and never reaches earth’s surface. It is the UVB that causes
most of the problems related to sun exposure: like aging, wrinkles and cancer2.
The SPF of a sunscreen is a laboratory measure of the effectiveness of
sunscreen. The higher the SPF, higher the protection offered by a sunscreen
against UV-B. The SPF is the amount of UV radiation required to cause sunburn
on skin with the the sunscreen with respect to the
amount required without the sunscreen3. Aloe vera serves for numerous purposes.
It is used both internally and externally for multiple functions.
It is widely used for treating various digestive and
dermatological disorders. It acts as immunomodulator
and is used for skin care applications4.
MATERIAL AND METHOD:
Materials:
Aloe vera freeze dried powder was obtained from Anjaneyulu herbals, Vijayawada. Sodium alginate, calcium
chloride, bentonite, zinc oxide and calamine were
purchased from S.D. fine- chem. Ltd, Mumbai. All Chemicals and solvents used in
the study were of analytical reagent grade. Fresh distilled water was used.
Preparation of
calamine lotion5:
Calamine lotion was formulated as per IP 1996. Sodium citrate was added
to 70 ml of distilled water in a mortar to this accurately weighed Calamine,
zinc oxide and bentonite were added and triturated
well in one direction to form a paste. To the paste liquified
phenol, glycerin were added and triturated. Finally
made up the volume to require volume with remaining quantity of water and the
lotion was transferred into clean and dry bottle.
Preparation of Conventional lotion6:
The conventional
lotion was prepared by incorporating 200mg aloe gel directly into 100ml of
calamine lotion IP.
Preparation of Novel lotion7:
Preparation of
beads:
Beads were prepared by ionic gelation
technique. Disperse 100 mg of Sodium alginate solution in 5 ml of distilled
water add 20mg of freeze dried powder of aloe , mixed using magnetic stirrer ( Remi, India) for 5 min. This was then extruded via syringe
(no-18) into 10% calcium chloride solution with gentle agitation at 37°C. The
formed beads were allowed to stand for 5 min in the solution, separated by
filtration through whattman filter paper.
Novel lotion was prepared by suspending beads equivalent to 200mg aloe
gel in 100 ml of calamine lotion IP.
Freeze-Dried Aloe vera Gel Preparation:
The freeze dried powder was obtained from the
market. Its ratio of AVG to lyophilized powder was 10:1. So quantity equivalent
to 200mg of gel was weighed and suspended into 100ml of calamine lotion.
EVALUATION OF BEADS7:
Morphology of beads: The mean diameter of dried beads was measured using
optical microscope.
Crushing strength: The beads of aloe gel were pressed over butter paper
to observe the crushing of beads to access its handling during application of
lotion.
EVALUATION OF LOTIONS:
Colour and PH : Colour was
observed with naked eye, to observe the compatibility with skin. PH of lotions was
determined by using pH meter.
Rheological
studies:
Viscosity8:
Viscosity of the lotions
was determined by Brookfield viscometer.
Spreadability9: Spreadability of
formulation was determined with the apparatus proposed andfabricated
by Multimer et al.
Physical
stability:
Sedimentation
volume10: All
the lotions were allowed to stand for 24hrs and sedimentation volume (F) was
calculated by using standard formula.
F= Ultimate volume of the
sediment
Initial volume of sediment
Redispersibility11: Redispersibility
of lotion was observed after 24hrs by its flocculation by shaking.
Freeze thaw method12: Stability testing was done by
using freeze thaw cycling method. The temperature was altered every 24 hours
between 25°C and -5°C for two cycles and
samples were observed for physical stability.
Creaming13: Creaming property for 5ml of each lotion
was determined by keeping them at refrigerated temperature (-4ºc) for 24hrs and
separation of solid and liquid phase were observed.
Effectiveness
Sensitivity of
lotion: Six volunteers
(20-25yrs), after applying the lotions on forearm for 20 minutes, observed for
any irritation or edema formation.
Psychometric effect7: Lotion was applied twice a day
once in morning (9.00a.m) and once in evening (5.00p.m) over five volunteers
(20-22yrs) upto 7 days and observations were noted verbly for firmness, softness, smoothness and lusture of skin.
Sun protection factor
determination:
In Vitro SPF
determination14:
In Vitro SPF can be determined by modified spectral analysis method
described by Mansur et al 14.
SPF=C.F.255Σ350.EE(λ).Abs.(λ)
Where,
CF=Correction factor, EE (λ) =
Erythmogenic effect of radiation with wavelength λ, Abs. (λ) = spectrophotometric
absorbance values of a solution of the preparation at λ.
In Vivo SPF
determination:
Five volunteers (20-22 yrs) with their willingness were included in the
study. A rubber sheet of the forearm length, with three circles of 2.5 cm
diameter each was used to cover the forearm. Each volunteer applied 2 mg/cm2
of lotions to volar forearm at separated area with
the use of the rubber sheet as regulator. For universal spread of lotion, 5 standardised circular hand movements were used. Five
volunteers were subjected to sun exposure following application of study
lotions and the time taken for the appearance of primary outcome measures like
development of erythema(redness) is noted.
SPF = The time required to produce erythema with protected area
The time required to produce erythema
with unprotected area
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:
The prepared conventional lotion and freeze dried aloe
powder lotion were evaluated for physical, rheological and stability
parameters. The pH of the lotion indicates that they were slightly
basic (Table 1), compatible with the skin. All the formulations were pink in colour. The rheological properties like viscosity and spreadability values indicate that they can be easily
handled during application. The lotions were easily redispersible
by slight shaking though they underwent sedimentation. Sedimentation volume
values indicate that freeze dried aloe powder lotion was more stable than
conventional lotion. The sensitivity test, psychometric effect test, indicates
that lotions were compatible with the skin.
The in vitro
SPF value for freeze dried aloe powder lotion was found to be more than
conventional lotion(Table 2). For freeze dried powder lotion, in vitro SPF by Mansur et al method was found to be 13.52±0.21
and the percentage UVB blockage was found to be 46.85% by the spectral
transmittance method and the UVA ratio was found to be
Table: 1 The evaluated parameters of various lotions
Evaluation parameter |
Calamine lotion |
Aloe gel lotion |
Freeze dried powder lotion |
Novel lotion |
I) Physical evaluation |
||||
a) PH |
10.05 |
9.8 |
8.9 |
7.24 |
b) Colour |
pink |
pink |
pink |
pink |
II) Rheological study |
|
|
|
|
a) Viscosity(cps) |
900 |
1070 |
1150 |
1260 |
b) spreadability(gm.cm/sec) |
12.5 |
13.3 |
16.6 |
------- |
III)Stability |
||||
a). sedimentation
volume |
0.67 |
0.7 |
0.77 |
0.81 |
b) redispersibility |
Redispersible |
Redispersible |
Redispersible |
Redispersible |
c) Freeze thaw
cycle |
Forms aggregate |
Forms aggregate |
Forms aggregate |
Forms aggregate |
d) creaming |
Separation of
phases |
Separation of
phases |
Separation of
phases |
Separation of
phases |
IV) Effectiveness |
||||
a) SPF in vivo |
2.84±0.72 |
3.07±0.58 |
10.03±1.017 |
12.23±0.36 |
b) SPF in vitro |
------ |
6.39±0.1 |
13.52±0.21 |
------ |
c) sensitivity |
No irritation |
No irritation |
No irritation |
No irritation |
d) Psychometric
effect |
No change was
observed |
No change was
observed |
No change was
observed |
No change was
observed |
Table 2: In -vitro
determination of SPF values of aloe vera conventional and freeze dried powder lotions:
S. No |
Wave length |
EE value |
Mean abs of freeze dried lotion(2mg/ml) |
% Transmission
of aloe gel lotion |
Mean abs of
aloe gel lotion(2mg/ml) |
% Transmission
of freeze dried lotion |
1 |
290 |
.0150 |
0.354±0.05 |
44.6 |
0.162 |
68.8 |
2 |
295 |
.0817 |
0.326±0.07 |
47.1 |
0.150 |
70.7 |
3 |
300 |
.2874 |
0.298±0.12 |
50.7 |
0.137 |
72.9 |
4 |
305 |
.3278 |
0.273±0.04 |
53.6 |
0.125 |
74.9 |
5 |
310 |
.1864 |
0.238±0.08 |
57.2 |
0.115 |
76.7 |
6 |
315 |
.0839 |
0.226±0.05 |
59.3 |
0.097 |
79.9 |
7 |
320 |
.018 |
0.224±0.07 |
59.6 |
0.084 |
82.4 |
8 |
325 |
----- |
0.212±0.09 |
61.3 |
0.072 |
86.8 |
9 |
330 |
----- |
0.204±0.15 |
61.5 |
0.066 |
87.5 |
10 |
335 |
----- |
0.201±0.11 |
62.9 |
0.062 |
88.1 |
11 |
340 |
----- |
0.190±0.06 |
64.4 |
0.056 |
88.9 |
13 |
345 |
----- |
0.181±0.05 |
65.7 |
0.050 |
89.1 |
14 |
350 |
----- |
0.167±0.06 |
67.9 |
0.046 |
89.7 |
15 |
355 |
----- |
0.165±0.11 |
68.2 |
0.040 |
90.2 |
16 |
360 |
----- |
0.158±0.09 |
69.4 |
0.036 |
91.9 |
17 |
365 |
----- |
0.155±0.12 |
69.9 |
0.035 |
92.1 |
18 |
370 |
----- |
0.149±0.05 |
70.8 |
0.030 |
93.1 |
19 |
375 |
----- |
0.146±0.07 |
71.3 |
0.028 |
93.5 |
20 |
380 |
----- |
0.140±0.11 |
72.4 |
0.026 |
93.9 |
21 |
385 |
----- |
0.135±0.08 |
73.1 |
0.024 |
94.2 |
22 |
390 |
----- |
0.130±0.13 |
74.1 |
0.022 |
94.9 |
23 |
395 |
----- |
0.122±0.08 |
75.4 |
0.022 |
94.9 |
24 |
400 |
----- |
0.109±O.07 |
77.6 |
0.021 |
95.1 |
Table 3: In
vitro testing parameters for conventional and Freeze dried powder lotions
S. No |
Parameter |
Freeze dried powder lotion |
Aloevera conventional lotion |
1 |
In-vitro SPF |
13.52±0.21 |
6.39±0.1 |
2 |
UVA and UVB blocking capacity |
46.85 and 34.26 |
13.94 and 24.9 |
3 |
UVA ratio |
1.322 |
0.729 |
4 |
Critical wavelength |
385 |
370 |
Table4: The evaluated parameters of the microcapsules
S. No |
Evaluation parameter |
Result |
1 |
Shape |
Spherical |
2 |
Diameter |
0.510±0.143mm |
3 |
Crushing strength |
Powder exudes out |
TABLE 5: In vivo determination of SPF values of
freeze dried lotions:
S.No |
Time to produce erythema on intact skin(min) |
Time to produce erythema for calamine
lotion(min) |
Time to produce erythema for freeze dried
lotion(min) |
Time to produce erythema for freeze dried
powder alone (min) |
SPF |
1 |
10 |
30 |
132.1 |
102.1 |
10.21 |
2 |
12 |
33 |
150.6 |
117.6 |
9.82 |
3 |
15 |
40 |
166.9 |
126.9 |
8.46 |
4 |
8 |
25 |
114.8 |
89.8 |
11.23 |
5 |
11 |
30 |
144.4 |
114.4 |
10.42 |
TABLE 6: In vivo determination of SPF values of
conventional lotions:
S.No |
Time to produce erythema on intact skin(min) |
Time to produce erythema for calamine
lotion(min) |
Time to produce erythema for aloe gel
lotion(min) |
Time to produce erythema for aloe gel
alone(min) |
SPF |
1 |
10 |
30 |
64.5 |
34.5 |
3.45 |
2 |
12 |
33 |
67.5 |
34.5 |
2.88 |
3 |
15 |
40 |
76.6 |
36.6 |
2.44 |
4 |
8 |
25 |
56.3 |
31.3 |
3.91 |
5 |
11 |
30 |
59.7 |
29.7 |
2.73 |
1.322( If UVA ratio >0.8, it is considered as a good
UVA blocker), as determined by Boot star system and the critical wavelength was
found to be 385( If c>370, it is considered as a broad range sun screen protectant) from critical wavelength method for
conventional lotion, SPF by Mansur et al method was found to be 6.39±0.1. the
percentage UVB blockage was found to be 24.9 by the spectral transmittance
method. UVA ratio was found to be 0.970 (If >0.8, it is considered to be a
good UVA blocker). By critical wavelength method the critical wavelength was
found to be 375 ( If >370, it is considered as a broad range sun screen protectant). By observing and comparing the above
data(Table 3), it can be concluded that the freeze dried powder lotion provides
greater sunscreen protection than the conventional lotion.
Correlation between the SPF value measured by the in vitro method and the in vivo method was shown in the fig.1and
2. The absorption of the sunscreen ingredient by the skin may be a determinant
factor for the SPF value for the in vivo
method. The difference in skin prototype probably lead to this bias. Subjects
with skin prototypes I, II and III were suggested for in vivo testing by the US, European countries and Japan, while
subjects with skin type II, III, and IV were recruited in this study. The
minimum erythemal dose (MED) for unprotected skin of
types II, III and IV were expected to be larger than those for types I. As a
result the time taken for the erythemal appearance on
the skin of the type II, III,IV prototypes was found to be more.
Another strategy we tried to promote stability is to
produce bead form of freeze dried Aloe vera leaf gel powder using ionic gelation
technique. The formation of beads of freeze dried aloe vera leaf gel powder using calcium
alginate was a simple and rapid process. Beads formed were in spherical shape
and having diameter 0.510mm±0.143. When beads were pressed over butter paper
freeze dried aloe vera
leaf gel powder exudes out easily showing easy to squeezing of gel from
bead at the time of application(Table 4). The prepared novel lotion was also
evaluated for physical and rheological parameters. The pH of
the novel lotion was found to be 7.24 which indicate that it is more compatible
with the skin compared with other lotions. Sedimentation volume values indicate
that novel lotion was most stable of all lotions. The sensitivity test,
psychometric effect test, indicates that novel lotion was compatible with the
skin. The in vivo SPF value of novel
lotion (Table 5) was found to be higher than other prepared lotions(Table 6).
The polymer concealed the core material from the external environment and as a
result, its potency was retained and also the ability of polymers to reflect
the UV radiation aids in it.
CONCLUSION:
The present work concluded that herbal extract can be
incorporated into lotions with compatibility. Freeze dried Aloe vera leaf gel powder can be
incorporated in lotions to improve the protection of skin for long duration
from UV exposure. The ionic gelation technique can be
used successfully for promoting the stability of freeze dried Aloe vera leaf
gel powder.
REFERENCES:
1.
Principles of anatomy and physiology by Gerard J. Tortora and Bryan Derrickson, 11th edition, 2006; chapter 5, 145-162.
2.
Mukhtar H, Elmets C. A. Photocarcinogenisis: mechanisms, models and human health
implications. Photochem protobiol
1996; 63, 355-447.
3.
Stege H, Budde, Grether-beck, Richard, Rougier, Ruzicka, Krutmann. Sunscreens with high SPF values are not
equivalent in protection from UVA induced polymorphous light eruption. European
journal of dermatology 2002; 12(4): 4-6.
4.
Forever Good Health, The Aloe Way, health care
magazine, Forever Living Products; India, Pvt. Ltd, 2009; 3-22.
5.
Indian Pharmacopoeia 1996, Ministry of Health nd Family Welfare, The controller of publications, New
Delhi, Volume-1, 1996:123.
6.
Ashawat M S, Saraf S,
Swarnalata Saraf. Comparative sun protection factor determination of fresh aloe vera gel vs marketed formulation. Indian J Pharm. Educ. Res 2008;
42(4): 319-322.
7.
Shika Srivastava, Shweta kapoor, Swarnalata Saraf. Novel preparation and evaluation of lotion
containing aloe gel beads. Indian J Pharm. Educ. Res 2008; 42(2): 170-173.
8.
Sankar V, Chandrasekaran A K, Durga S.
Formulation and stability evaluation of diclofenac
sodium ophthalmic gels. Indian J. of Pharm. Sci
2005;67(4): 473-476.
9.
Sakarkar D M, Shrikhande V N. Studies on formulation development,
characterization and transdermal permeation of nimesulide
from emulgel. Int. J. Pharma.
Excip 2004;3(3):57-61.
10.
Patrick j. sinko, physical,
chemical and biopharmaceutical principles in the pharmaceutical sciences,
martins physical pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences, 2005; 5th edition:502.
11.
Leon Lachman, Herbert A.
Lieberman, Joseph L. Kanig, The Theory and practice
of Industrial Pharmacy, 3rd edition, Varghese publication House,
Bombay,1987,493.
12.
Sreenivasa reddy M, Mutalik S.Preparation and evaluation of minoxidil
gels for topical application in alopecia. Indian J. Of Pharm. Sci. 2006;
68(4):432-436.
13.
Spruce, S.R; J.P. Hewitt, In vitro SPF methodology
and correlation with In vivo data. Euro cosmetics. June 1995;14-20.
14.
Freitas Z M F, Goncalves J C S, Santos E P and Vergnainin
A. Glyceridic Esters Of P- Methoxy
cinnamic acid. A new Sun screen of the cinnamate class. Int. J. Cosmetic sciences 2001;23,147.
Received
on 28.12.2010 Accepted
on 05.05.2011
©A&V
Publications all
right reserved
Res. J. Topical and Cosmetic Sci. 2(2): July – Dec. 2011 page 66-70